Road Trip: Beer Pong

The reason for this is because one day, when Andy is playing beer pong with his friends, Korkin (Trotter) and Jake (Absera), the latter also being the best beer pong player at Ithaca, Andy recognizes the person behind a life-size cardboard cutout of a beer pong model. This model, Jenna (Levy-Boeken), had been Andy's first crush, before he even met Katy. Upon sharing this information with Korkin, Korkin convinces Andy to catch up with the beer pong tour so he can see Jenna again. Jake also goes along, because he and Andy are also to compete against another university in Atlanta. Since Ithaca only pays for their trip to Atlanta, the three try to get Arash (Pudi), the son of a dictator of the island of Tandor, to sponsor their trip, but when they go to see Arash, they all end up taken into custody by the CIA (on Andy and Katy's "special night"), who then dumps them in Bethesda. After this, the guys steal a taxi and continue on their journey - Arash is now broke because he learned his father was overthrown. However, in a twist of irony, they pick up a hitchhiker, who ends up robbing a convenience store and stealing "their" taxi (while all four guys are in the store).

Just when Andy is about to turn him, Arash, Korkin, and Jake in, a bus filled with beautiful girls, who believe in "Chastity Until Marriage," stops, and Sarah (Terrazzano), the driver, offers the guys a ride to Nashville. Korkin initially lied about them coming from a religious retreat, but he eventually tells Sarah why the guys are really on the road. Upon finding out Sarah's father is also the priest who founded the Chastity movement, Korkin makes it his mission to sleep with Sarah. Korkin arranges for Katy's mother to let everyone on the Chastity Chastity bus spend a night at her home, as they happened to be driving through the area. While at Katy's mother's, Sarah admits "most guys don't have the balls to go after a preacher's daughter, despite [their] reputation for being naughty;" eventually, Korkin does sleep with Sarah, and she even becomes his girlfriend later.

Eventually, the guys do catch up with the beer pong tournament in Nashville, and Andy does get to see Jenna. Jenna also convinces Andy to play his popular song, "In the Buff," a song he wrote and videotaped himself playing for Katy, on stage. Apparently, Korkin had accidentally posted the "In the Buff" videotape to Youtube, and Andy had become famous. Andy's beer pong festival performance of the song also gets caught on tape, along with footage of him and Jenna kissing onstage. Unfortunately, Katy sees this video on Youtube, and is initially upset, but she gets over it and realizes that she had made a mistake herself by transferring to Ithaca just to be around Andy. Andy also thinks about having sex with Jenna, like he almost did during the week he and Jenna were in love, but he ultimately realizes Katy is the one for him. Nevertheless, Andy and Katy agree to designate each other as "back home honeys."